A new season of From won't arrive until at least 2026, meaning there will be a long wait before we find out what's going to happen next for the many characters trapped within town. But until that time, you might consider checking out one of the shows on this list, all of which are scarier or more intense than the MGM+ series. It'd be a good way to keep yourself entertained until season 4 finally debuts!
Midnight Mass
If the isolated nature of the small cyclical town at the heart of From appeals to you then might I suggest another series about a reclusive community shut off from the rest of civilization, also featuring terrifying creatures on the prowl. Midnight Mass shares some common themes with From and popular Stephen King works like Salem’s Lot. An insular island community falls under the sway of an enigmatic and cult-like priest who brings a mysterious new religious dogma and supposed miracles to the easily led congregation.
Dark
Before we get into the benefits of watching this excellent German Netflix show, I will note that it’s not necessarily scary in the traditional sense. It plays into realistic and grounded fears of losing a loved one. The entire premise revolves around the initial disappearance of a teenager in the woods, but Dark is far more complex and fascinating than your average crime thriller. For anyone doubting the direction of From’s story, maybe with concerns that the writers won’t be able to wrap everything up in a satisfying way, I give you a show that had a near-perfect three season run.
The Terror
An underrated anthology horror drama that started in 2018, with its first season based on the events of Dan Simmons' novel of the same name. From might deal with the terrifying possibility of being trapped in a town you can never leave, but The Terror sees a group of explorers becoming frozen and trapped in ice, forced to contend with brutal weather conditions and a lurking monster. Season 2 focuses on a WWII horror story. A third season based on Victor LaVelle's novel Devil in Silver is in the works.
Evil
Evil is great for anyone seeking something a little more lighthearted and less serialized. A psychologist teams up with a priest-in-training and a tech-savvy contractor to investigate potential cases of demonic possession for the Catholic church. Every episode deals with a different case and the writers play coy with confirming or denying the existence of the supernatural as each episode provides both a plausible explanation and an otherworldly one. It’s left up to the audience to decide what they believe.
Channel Zero
Another underrated anthology horror show, Channel Zero ran for four seasons on Syfy. Each season adapts a popular creepypasta story. The stories vary from a terrifying children's television show, to a haunted house, to mysterious basement door. It's a surprisingly adept and well-made show, and even if you don't like one season you can always try another. The First Omen director Arkasha Stevenson directed the show's third season.