Since Shudder is one of the most popular premiere horror streaming services in existence right now, the app's catalog can be quite daunting to explore. There are dozens upon dozens of horror movies on the streamer and it's hard to know which ones are worth watching or not. With plenty of different subgenres, the choices can quickly become overwhelming.
The following list highlights some of the most jaw-dropping movies currently available to watch on Shudder. If you're just looking for something scary that is guaranteed to shock you, then look no further than the six movies listed below.
Rust Creek (2018)
Rust Creek is a great film to watch if you want to feel like your heart is in your throat the entire time. It's not graphic, but it has a deeply tense vibe throughout the entire thing that will keep you on edge. It centers on a student who gets lost on a road trip and attracts unwanted attention from a group of criminals. Thinking she witnessed them do something illegal, they try to hunt her down and silence her permanently.
The Ugly Stepsister (2025)
This Norwegian body horror film reinvents the classic Cinderella fairy tale and distorts it into something nightmarish, disturbing, and also darkly hilarious. Elvira's mother tasks her with attracting a wealthy suitor to take care of their family, but not believing her natural beauty is up to the task, she employs a number of barbaric practices like eating a tapeworm and having eyelashes sewn in to enhance her looks and achieve her task. There are plenty of jaw-dropping moments in this film and it's possible you might even lose your lunch, so you might want to watch it on a light stomach.
When Evil Lurks (2023)
Brutal as well as jaw-dropping, When Evil Lurks is one of the best horror movies released in 2023 and it's an unrelenting movie, one where no one is safe. There are several scenes in this film that will make you sit there in shock and awe. This Argentinian horror film revolves around a demonic infestation in a rural town that appears impossible to stop.
Fréwaka (2024)
Like The Ugly Stepsister, Fréwaka is a newer release that just arrived on Shudder this year. Shoo lives in a remote Irish village taking care of a reclusive elderly woman. Haunted by her religious past, Shoo's patient is constantly in fear of something coming for her. This folk horror movie entrances you just like it does with its characters as Shoo is further drawn into her patient's dark web.
The Snowtown Murders (2011)
Also known as just "Snowtown," this movie is one of the most disturbing and graphic Australian films ever made. It's definitely not for anyone faint of heart. The biographical crime thriller is based on a true story and features graphic depictions of assault as it follows a violent predator taking his girlfriend's son under his wing and turning him into his murderous accomplice.
Overlord (2018)
Overlord is an underrated little film released in 2018 that presents an alternate reality about what happened to the American soldiers who discover horrific Nazi experiments in the 1940s. This is not your typical war movie by any means, it's a very strange and often gross body horror flick that is quite entertaining and more action-oriented than some of the other options on this list.