If you're a horror buff, you already know A24 doesn't play by the rules. Their films don’t just scare, they unravel you. With haunting imagery, psychological torment, and an unshakable sense of dread, they burrow deep into your mind and leave a lasting, unsettling mark. This is why A24 horror movies are often not just a viewing experience, but a challenge to your very sense of comfort.
They force you to confront your darkest fears and leave you questioning what you just witnessed, making it nearly impossible to shake the unsettling feeling of unease that lingers after. But while most of A24's horror content is unforgettable, some of their films go even further, plunging you into a level of terror so intense that watching them once is often more than enough.
In this article, we've rounded up five of the most disturbing A24 horror films and shared them below. These movies are so unnerving that you'll be left questioning if you ever want to watch them again.
The Witch (2015)
- Where to watch: Available to rent or purchase via digital retailers
Anya Taylor-Joy is already a very talented actress, but her role in The Witch truly showcased her range, solidifying her as one of the most captivating young stars in horror today. Then, with Robert Eggers being behind this film, it was bound to be a haunting masterpiece. Set in 17th-century New England, the story follows a Puritan family that, after being banished from their community, sets up a farm near a dark and mysterious forest. After they begin to experience strange and disturbing events, they start to suspect that the eldest daughter may be involved in witchcraft. Plagued by paranoia and fear, the family begins to unravel, turning on each other as suspicion grows.
Saint Maud (2020)
- Where to watch: Prime Video, MGM+
There’s a lot to unpack with Saint Maud, but one thing is certain: it’s a deeply unsettling psychological horror that delves into the dark territories of obsession, faith, and isolation. Morfydd Clark stars as Maud, a devout Roman catholic and troubled nurse who becomes fixated on saving the soul of her terminally ill patient, Amanda, who is an atheist. Maud believes that God has given her a mission to lead Amanda to salvation before her death. However, Amanda resists Maud’s attempts to impose her faith on her, which causes growing tension between them. As Maud's obsession deepens, the line between devotion and madness begins to blur, leading her to spiral into dangerous delusions. This only makes the situation even more intense and unsettling.
Midsommar (2019)
- Where to watch: Available to rent or buy on digital platforms
Midsommar gave Florence Pugh another shot at the horror genre after her not-so-great experience with Malevolent, and boy did she knock it out of the park. In this must-see folk horror, Pugh plays Dani, an American woman deep in mourning after a tragic loss, who joins her boyfriend and friends on a trip to a secluded Swedish village for a midsummer festival. But what should've been a peaceful getaway soon spirals into a horrifying ordeal as the group gets caught up in the village's eerie and age-old customs.
Talk to Me (2023)
- Where to watch: Netflix, Paramount+
Talk to Me is the type of movie that, once you've watched it, you can't stop thinking about it. With its chilling premise and intense psychological horror, it pulls you in from the first moment and refuses to let go. Sophie Wilde portrays the role of a teenage girl named Mia, who is still having a hard time processing the death of her mom a few years back. She finally starts to feel connected again when she’s introduced to a bizarre party game involving an embalmed hand that supposedly lets people communicate with spirits. But what begins as harmless fun quickly turns dark when sinister spirits are accidentally released into the real world.
Hereditary (2018)
- Where to watch: Tubi for free
What’s the best way to describe Hereditary? It’s a slow-burn horror that starts as a deeply unsettling family drama centered around grief and loss, before slowly transforming into something much darker and more disturbing. The film pulls you in with its emotional depth, only to leave you rattled and terrified by its shocking twists and constant, suffocating sense of dread.
After losing the matriarch of their family, the Grahams are left to deal with the aftermath of her death. As they attempt to move forward, unsettling events begin to occur, leading them to uncover chilling secrets about their family’s past. As the horrors escalate, they are faced with the horrifying realization that they are trapped by a dark, inherited legacy, and the supernatural forces at play are far more dangerous and inescapable than they ever imagined.